Peanut Butter & Ice Cream!

Peanut butter cup and Ice cream!! OH EM GEE this combination is soooo delicious! This ice cream sandwich will put all other ice cream sandwiches to shame!! As soon as I mentioned this concoction brought to us by HERSHEY’S to my kids they were all for it and fetched the ingredients…. FAST!!


what you need:

  • 18 REESE’S Snack Size Peanut Butter Cups
  • 36 flat cookies (2 to 2-1/2 inch) , purchased or homemade (we went with homemade, mmm yummy homemade, warm cookies right out of the oven!)

what to do:

  1. Remove wrappers from peanut butter cups. For each sandwich cookie, place one peanut butter cup on flat side of one cookie; place on paper towel.
  2. Microwave at MEDIUM (50%) 10 to 15 seconds; gently press second cookie on peanut butter cup. Wait several minutes for peanut butter cup to soften and adhere to second cookie. Eat immediately or allow chocolate to set before storing cookies. Makes 18 sandwich cookies.

Perfect for so many different occasions, or simply a surprise treat for movie night like we did! We usually hold a family movie night once a week, highlight a 80/90s movie (you should see the look on my kids faces), popcorn, candy, and this movie night we made these peanut butter cup ice cream sandwiches! A delicious and sweet and to a perfect, summer, family movie night. I’d like to try and take this to the next level with HERSHEY’S chocolate bars, ice cream, marshmallows and graham crackers for smore’s sandwiches!! How do you like your sweet treats?! Have you come up with any “must have” combos?! Share them with us!

For more delicious recipes, and amazing savings with HERSHEY’S, visit us over at!!