​Whose Turn Is It Anyway? A Guide to Alternating Holidays as a Military Family

Pull up a chair and let’s talk about the unspoken side of the holiday season…the side that involves color-coded calendars and trying to explain military leave to relatives who think you can just “take a personal day” to make Thanksgiving dinner.

If you’ve ever found yourself sitting on the living room floor in early October trying to solve the complex mathematical equation of dividing ten days of leave between two sets of in-laws, three states, and four different holiday dinners, all while keeping your own household sane, you are far from alone.

​When you live miles away from home, every holiday carries the heavy pressure of expectation. Extended family misses you, you miss them, and suddenly the calendar isn’t just a way to keep track of days…it’s an emotional tug-of-war with your reality and emotions.

​Here is how to navigate the split-holiday rotation with the people you love, and protect the peace of your own home this season while doing it:

• ​Ditch the “50/50 Split” Math
  • ​The biggest trap military families fall into is trying to make every single holiday leave window “100% fair” down to the hour. 
  • ​You try to spend four days with one side of the family, pack up the kids and suitcases, drive sixteen hours across state lines, and spend the exact same amount of time with the other side. By the time your leave ends and you get back home, you need a vacation from your vacation. The kids are overtired, you and your spouse are exhausted, and nobody actually got quality rest.
  • ​The Shift: Stop treating holiday leave like a business negotiation. Fairness doesn’t mean splitting a single 7-day window down the middle; it means creating a predictable, multi-year rhythm where everyone gets dedicated, unhurried time that will leave lasting memories for everyone.

• Establish the “Odd/Even Year” Rotation
  • ​The simplest way we found to eliminate the endless “is it fair” split we found ourselves fighting was to establish a clear, set-in-stone rotation early on and stick to it.​ When you lock this schedule in for the long haul, extended family stops wondering “Where are they going this year?” and begins anticipating their designated turn, and the guilt and exhaustion of splitting a week of time with two separate families disappears. 
  • Simple Rotation Model
    • ​Even Years: Thanksgiving with his Family and Christmas with your Family.
    • Odd Years: Thanksgiving with your Family and Christmas with his Family.
• Give Yourself Permission to Plant Roots at Home
  • ​There comes a point in every military family’s journey where living out of suitcases over Christmas morning simply becomes unrealistic. You live too far from everyone, to be able to fairly split the holidays with odd/even years.  Choosing to stay in your own home for a major holiday is not “excluding” your extended family…it’s accepting that the financial burden of flying two months back to back across the United States isn’t realistic. 
  • ​If you have to stay put, let everyone know your door is open if travel permits, or take the time to call each set on Christmas morning with a mug in hand, and let them watch presents be opened through video chat that they sent. Our kids’ grandparents always love watching them open their gifts, and video chat has been such a huge blessing for us. Just ensure you lose the feeling of guilt for making your current house the holiday anchor when knowing it is the best choice for your immediate family.

• ​Build “Different” Traditions
  • ​Remember that  Thanksgiving Day or Christmas do not hold a monopoly on family love.
  • ​If leave schedules, flight costs, or duty rotations mean you can’t make it home for the official date, reframe the calendar. Plan a summer visit, where no one gets a holiday, but everyone gets quality time. Try hosting a “Friendsgiving” in your military community, you’re not the only ones who couldn’t make it home for the holidays.
  • ​Quality time spent on a random week in June often creates far deeper, less stressful memories than a rushed, high-pressure holiday visit in December.

​One final thought for your heart here folks…at the end of the day, extended family reactions, even the disappointed ones, usually stem from a place of loving you deeply and wanting you close. Validate that love, but hold your boundaries with confidence knowing you’re putting your family’s well-being first…even though the situation isn’t easy for anyone.

​You are allowed to protect your household family’s energy, your budget, and your peace. Whether you are driving across three states, hosting extended family at your table, or staying cozy in your own living room with sourdough cinnamon rolls and pajamas before the neighbors come over for supper, remember that the true heart of the season is the love and peace you create inside your own four walls that your tiniest feet will always remember.

Find Out More with My Military Savings and Military Life & Family!